Poll: Should Reputation Comments be publicly viewable?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes
36.84%
7 36.84%
No
47.37%
9 47.37%
What's a Reputation Comment?
15.79%
3 15.79%
Total 19 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Reputation Comments
#11
Gimme, post: 1441878 Wrote:I might just stop giving rep altogether.

If I started posting again would that help you continue to give Rep in the future?
Reply
#12
Hello Birthday Boy, where's ya bin?

I waited at Pomeroys for you.
[COLOR=rgb(255, 140, 0)]MY AVATAR: [SIZE=4]1967 WEG tiger[/SIZE][/COLOR]
Reply
#13
I voted no simply because I thought the message was personal: for the recipient if you wanted to explain why you (of all people) were suddenly giving a thumbs up.

In the olden days, we used to display who had liked a post. That was fine as it gave an idea of who liked what and keen players could troll for votes (NTTAWWT). Post of the month etc.

I reckon that if we are making the comments visible, we should make the rep visible as well. Otherwise, keep it between the players. This is a bit of hybrid.
Now then now then now now then now now then then now now then. Now then!
Reply
#14
If people didn't know before at least they know now that rep comments are public. That I think is the main thing.
Reply
#15
I'd give you rep for that but I'm in a holding pattern on the whole thing.
[COLOR=rgb(255, 140, 0)]MY AVATAR: [SIZE=4]1967 WEG tiger[/SIZE][/COLOR]
Reply
#16
I was a yes too.
I thought it was a promotion for positive comment, so am happy for people to see why I recieve and why I dish it out. Angel
No.8 Dick Clay 213g(1966-76), Michael Roach 200g 607goals(1977-89), Alan Geddes 182g 1925-43), Robert Carew 45g(1919-22), Jack Riewoldt 225*g 537*goals(2007-)
Reply
#17
I just assumed it wasn't public. Guess I made an "ass" out of u and me.

I maintain that reputation comments should be private.

Squirrel!
Ms Tantie.
xox
2017 advocate for Nathan Drummond - on the rise...
Reply
#18
Sometimes I like to bag out people when I give rep...happy for all to see the mean things I say about Black, Jase, Rumps and Claw...
Reply
#19
Oh shit are they really public ?? bwahahahaaa ! Where can I view these ' public comments I thought were private ' ??


[COLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)] [/COLOR] THOSE MIGHTY TIGERS !
Reply
#20
I voted No as I believe it is like a PM. Sometimes it is because you agreed with the post at others it is to give the poster a gee up when they may think all is against them. Yes you could do a PM but for a single sentiment unseen rep is much easier.

Perhaps I am just lazy.
Sponsor of Daniel Butler 2015-17
2005-2014 Sponsor of Daniel Jackson

Member of Yellow and Black the greatest of all Football Sites.Cool
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Reputation score missing RichardMEL 7 1,265 20-08-2007, 22:29
Last Post: Ned

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)